Sellers of communal technology sanctioned for cartel agreements in public procurements
The breach of the Act on the Protection of Competition by eight companies has been proved by the Office.
By the first decision the Office fined undertakings GARNEA a.s. and GARDEN Studio, s.r.o. for coordination of bids within the awarding procedure “Purchase of garden equipment” of National Heritage Institute. The collusion had an actual impact on the outcome of mentioned awarding procedure and restricted the competition in the market of communal technology. For the competition infringement the fine of CZK 1,518,000 has been imposed on the company GARNEA and the fine of CZ 74 000 has been imposed on the company GARDEN Studio. Mentioned decision has not yet come into force and it may be appealed.
The second decision covered anticompetitive conduct of companies KIS plus, a.s. and GARDEN Studio during the awarding procedure “Supply of communal vehicle” conducted by the contracting authority Municipal Transport Office Plzen, a.s. from the year 2010. For influencing the outcome of the awarding procedure and restriction of competition in the market of communal technology a fine of CZK 1,501,000 has been imposed on the company KIS and a fine of CZK 74,000 on the company GARDEN Studio. The decision has already come into force.
By the third decision, sanctions of CZK 1,903,000 have been imposed on companies GARDEN Studio, s.r.o. (CZK 388,000), CHLEBIŠ s.r.o. (CZK 185,000), ŠKÝZ s.r.o. (CZK 62,000) AGROCAR s.r.o. (CZK 536,000) and on economically active natural persons M. Š. (CZK 614,000) and T. M. (CZK 118,000). The Office proved that mentioned undertakings shared the customers and supplies of communal technology according to territorial principle in the period from 22/3/2010 to 14/8/2012. Undertakings applied for settlement procedure and admitted the legal qualification of their behavior and therefore the fines were lowered by 20 %. The decision has not been appealed and has already come into force.
In all three cases the anticompetitive behavior has been proved by collected communication of parties of the cartel agreements and by comparing the bids. The largest of mentioned administrative proceedings conducted against the company KIS plus, a.s. had to be divided into two proceedings due to procedural reasons as the undertakings was not willing to apply for the settlement procedure.
Cartel agreements among bidders so called bid rigging represent the most serious types of competition law infringements as they totally restrict the competition within the public procurement and restrict the efficient use of public resources. It is estimated that as a consequence of the cartel the price of procurements rises by up to 20 %.
International and External Relations
14/093/HS037 – S123/2012, S230/2012, S835/2014
2025-01-08 / Google Made Changes to one of its Services in Reaction to the Investigation of the Office Last year, the Office for the Protection of Competition investigated possible abuse of a dominant position by Google Czech Republic, s.r.o, its parent company Google International LLC and Google Ireland...
2024-11-19 / Pet Food Supplier VAFO Has to Pay CZK 120 million for Prohibited Resale Price Fixing The Office for the Protection of Competition (hereinafter referred to as “the Office”) imposed a fine of CZK 120,121,000 on the undertaking VAFO PRAHA (hereinafter referred to as "VAFO") for the...
2024-10-16 / The Office is Conducting a Dawn Raid at the Premises of the Undertaking Seznam.cz Following numerous media inquiries, we confirm that the Office for the Protection of Competition (hereinafter referred to as “the Office“) is conducting an unannounced inspection of Seznam.cz
2024-10-01 / Merger of PPF Group and Nordic Telecom May Take Place Subject to Commitments The Office for the Protection of Competition has cleared the merger by its final decision, as a result of which PPF TMT Holdco 2 B.V. may acquire, through O2 Czech Republic a.s., sole control over Nordic...
2024-09-16 / The 2024 St. Martin's Conference Program Will Offer a new Competition Tool and Private Enforcement The Office for the Protection of Competition (hereinafter referred to as "the Office") is preparing the 17th annual St. Martin Conference on trends, news and hot topics in the field of competition. The...
2024-07-11 / English Version of Annual Report 2023 published The Office for the Protection of Competition presents the English version of its annual report for the year 2023, summarising the results of its activities in all areas of its competence, i.e., in the...
2024-06-19 / Office for the Protection of Competition Cooperates with European Public Prosecutor's Office Today in Luxembourg, Mr Petr Mlsna, the Chairman of the Office for the Protection of Competition, signed an agreement with the European chief prosecutor, Ms Laura Codruţa Kövesi, on cooperation between...
2024-05-09 / The Office Revealed and Punished Another Cartel Agreement between Construction Companies The Office for the Protection of Competition imposed fines totalling CZK 7,442,000 on the construction companies B.H.S. BOHEMIA, a.s., SEŽEV facility s.r.o., COMMODUM, spol. s r.o. and Hroší stavby...
