Road and Motorway Directorate unlawfully awarded a public contract for the repair of a bridge in Trutnov
The contracting authority violated the law when it awarded the above mentioned contract in the negotiated procedure without publication without fulfilling statutory conditions for the use of this type of an award procedure. The appeal against the first-instance decision was not lodged.
In November 2011, the contracting authority invited 5 candidates to submit tenders in negotiated procedure without publication, although an estimated value of a public contract was calculated for more than CZK 57 million excluding VAT. The contracting authority argued in defence of its procedure that the bridge was in serious disrepair and the fixing was necessary to be done promptly. However, the contracting authority had known about the poor condition of the bridge since at least 2007, when it commissioned a diagnostic survey of the construction. According to the Office, the contracting entity had sufficient information about the fact that the construction and technical conditions of the bridge will or may in the future continue to deteriorate and as such the statutory condition that the contracting entity could not predict the extreme urgency was not met in this case.
The Act allows the use of the negotiated procedure without publication only for reasons of extreme urgency that a contracting entity has not caused by its own conduct and that could not be even foreseen. The mentioned case does not meet these conditions and the negotiated procedure without publication was therefore chosen unlawfully.
The contracting entity by its procedure substantially affected the selection of the most suitable tender because if the contract had been awarded by a procedure where a contract notice is published and that allows mutual competition of suppliers, it is possible that the contracting entity could receive more suitable tender price from bidders who were not directly invite to the tender.
International and External Relations of the Office
2024-11-18 / The Office Has Received Appeals Against Decisions on the Tender for the Construction of Nuclear Power Plant The Office for the Protection of Competition (hereinafter referred as "the Office") has received appeals filed by Électricité de France and Westinghouse Electric Company LLC against the first instance...
2024-10-31 / The Office Decides on the Proposals of Westinghouse and EDF Against the Nuclear Tender Procedure In the First Instance The Office for the Protection of Competition (hereinafter referred to as "the Office") has decided in the first instance on the proposals of the companies Électricité de France and Westinghouse Electric...
2024-09-03 / Details on the Content of Westinghouse and EDF's Complainst Against Nuclear Tender Last week, the Office for the Protection of Competition (hereinafter referred to as “the Office”) received submisisons from Westinghouse Electric Company LLC and Électricité de France challenging...
2024-07-11 / English Version of Annual Report 2023 published The Office for the Protection of Competition presents the English version of its annual report for the year 2023, summarising the results of its activities in all areas of its competence, i.e., in the...
2024-06-19 / Office for the Protection of Competition Cooperates with European Public Prosecutor's Office Today in Luxembourg, Mr Petr Mlsna, the Chairman of the Office for the Protection of Competition, signed an agreement with the European chief prosecutor, Ms Laura Codruţa Kövesi, on cooperation between...
2023-06-28 / The Office has Published the English Version of Its Annual Report 2022 The Office for the Protection of Competition (hereinafter referred to as "the Office") has published the English version of its Annual report for 2022. In the publication you will find complete statistical...
2022-09-23 / Representatives of the Review Bodies on Public Procurement Discussed in Prague the Application of Sanctions and Exclusion of Suppliers On 23 September 2022, the 11th meeting of the Network of First Instance Review Bodies on Public Procurement took place in Prague as a part of the Czech Presidency of the Council of the European Union...
2022-07-29 / Annual Report 2021 The Office for the Protection of Competition (hereinafter referred to as “the Office”) publishes the English version of its Annual Report for the year 2021, during which it not only celebrated 30...
